cjou3368, Author at Jing (Catherine) Ou

November 22, 2020January 5, 2021

Evaluate the worldwide damages in the epidemic of defective computer graphic cards in the international sales of goods disputes – #40

I have participated in the 18th CIETAC Cup Commercial Arbitration Moot Competition as an arbitrator last week on a videoconference platform named VooV Meeting. It has been my great honour and privilege to sit with the experienced arbitrators and lawyers from different jurisdictions during this event. And we are glad to see that the students in China are able to plead the CISG related matters fluently in English and to answer our questions directly and effectively during their deliberations (See my one-minute speech as the Arbitrator of CIETAC Cup).

As you may already know, this year, the Problem concerns the applicability of United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (“CISG”) on the purchase and license agreement on the viral sectors for the production of vaccines against respiratory diseases, such as COVID-19. In the Problem, Claimant only requires the arbitral tribunal to declare the existence of a breach of contract of the Respondent as Claimant is not yet in a position, to exactly identify the specific remedy required. Out of curiosity, I have read a recent decision of Superior Court of Quebec to learn how the Quebec courts evaluate the worldwide damages in the epidemic of defective computer graphic cards litigation.

November 8, 2020November 15, 2020

Quand le locateur poursuit le locataire pour loyers impayés depuis la pandémie liée à la COVID-19… – #39

La COVID-19 fait des ravages auprès de plusieurs petites entreprises, notamment dans le domaine de la restauration. Certains restaurants ont de la difficulté à payer leur loyer tandis que les propriétaires des lieux loués doivent néanmoins continuer à payer les dépenses afférentes à l’immeuble. En avril 2020, le gouvernement du Canada a mis en place un programme d’aide d’urgence pour le loyer commercial (le programme AUCLC), dont le but est de réduire de 75 % le loyer des petites entreprises canadiennes les plus touchées par la pandémie de COVID-19. L’adhésion à ce programme exige la collaboration du locateur.

La Cour du Québec et la Cour supérieure du Québec ont récemment rendu plusieurs jugements sur des demandes d’ordonnance de sauvegarde portant sur la réclamation des loyers du baux commerciaux (Voir Investissement immobiliers G. Lazzara inc. c. 9224-5455 Québec, 2020 QCCS 2176 ; 9215-3956 Québec inc. c. 9378-9949 Québec inc., 2020 QCCQ 2537 ; Investissements Complexe 2020 ltée c. Madame Bovary inc., 2020 QCCS 2500 etc.).

Cet article vise à analyser la question suivante: dans quelle situation le locateur a-t-il droit à une ordonnance de sauvegarde en fonction des critères élaborés par la jurisprudence ?

November 1, 2020January 1, 2021

The CISG Governs the Sale of Computer Graphic Cards Contract While the Quebec Law Determines the Weight to be Given to Evidence by the Court – #38

The China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission (CIETAC) is hosting the 18th CIETAC Cup Commercial Arbitration Moot Competition in November 2020. I am going to participate in this online arbitration competition as an arbitrator. This year, the Problem concerns the applicability of United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (“CISG”) on the purchase and license agreement on the viral sectors for the production of vaccines against respiratory diseases, such as COVID-19. Out of curiosity, I have read a recent decision of Superior Court of Quebec to learn how the Quebec courts use CISG and domestic laws to decide “whether or not to award damages and, if so, for what amount” in the disputes arising out of a sale contract of the computer graphic cards between the multinational companies. The Court notes that while the CISG governs the sale of computer graphic cards contract, the rules applicable to evidence in this case are in the Book Seven of the Civil Code of Quebec.

Key Facts

In early 1998, the Plaintiff purchased the Defendant’s graphic cards for new Kayak and Vectra personal computers. The worldwide Business Desktop Division (“BDD”) of the Plaintiff operates primarily in Grenoble, France.

October 27, 2020October 27, 2020

魁省高等法院对受疫情影响下商事租约纠纷作出判决!

全国各地中小型企业因新冠疫情蔓延面临无法预料的挑战。在蒙特利尔，许多经营餐馆，健身房和服装店的华人朋友们都在为疫情期间营业额直线下滑，无法承担昂贵租金而发愁。今年七月中旬，魁省高等法院作出裁定表示，因响应政府公共卫生政策号召而暂停营业的企业可以酌情免除缴付房租的义务。

该案中，一个华人开的健身房不幸被房东告上法庭。房东要求健身房赔付今年三月到六月的房租。房东认为，即使健身房被迫暂停营业，健身房的器械依旧存放在原处；由于健身房已经获得了来自联邦政府的租客应急补助，健身房没有合法理由拒绝缴付房租。健身房则辩称，健身房的暂停营业是不可抗力造成的。根据魁省政府3月24日颁布的行政命令，由于健身房不被认定为维持人们生命健康和基本社会功能的城市基本核心服务，所有魁省的健身房都被勒令暂停营业以延缓新冠疫情的蔓延。因此，健身房的无法营业，无法产生营业额，无法支付房租是由不能预见，不能避免，不能克服的不可抗力因素造成的。根据魁北克民法典第1470条规定，健身房有权要求免除缴付被迫暂停营业期间的房租的责任。

October 18, 2020October 18, 2020

Mazzetta v. Dégust-Mer: Quebec Courts Have Jurisdiction as the CISG Governs the Sales Contract of the Frozen Lobsters – #36

The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) is designed to facilitate international trade and to remove legal barriers among Contracting States by providing substantive rules that regulate the duties and obligations of parties to a commercial transaction, such as the delivery of goods, contract formation, and remedies for breach of contract (See Preamble of the CISG). The CISG applies to contracts of sale of goods between parties whose places of business are in different Contracting States (See Art. 1 (1) (a) of CISG). As of October 2020, 94 states have ratified the CISG (See Updates on CISG). The USA is a signatory of CISG, which has been in effect there since 1986. Canada acceded to the CISG in 1992, and Quebec incorporated it into domestic law through An Act respecting the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods, which has been taken into effect since May 1, 1992. In April 2011, the Quebec Court of Appeal ruled on the disputes between a Quebec frozen lobster seller, Dégust-Mer, and an American company, Mazzeta, the buyer who had failed to pay for the sale and delivery fees of frozen lobsters (Mazzetta Company, l.l.c. c. Dégust-Mer inc., 2011 QCCA 717). This court decision reminds us that the governing law of this international sales of goods contract should be the CISG.

October 11, 2020October 11, 2020

“但愿人长久，千里共婵娟” —聊聊2020年加拿大父母团聚移民那些事儿

“嗨，你怎么还在呀！”我闻声抬起头，看到同事惊讶的眼神，我轻轻地回应道：“是啊，我想把这个庭前审问记录和那个上诉法院的案例看完再走……”

现在，整个办公室就剩我一人了。坐在蒙特利尔市西山区高级办公楼里，我望向窗外黑漆漆的夜色，看着那微弱的星星点点的街灯，回想着今天前辈律师给我的叮咛教导，肚子突然“咕咕咕”叫了起来。我转眼看电脑屏幕上的时间，呀，都已经晚上八点半了！我还没吃晚饭呢。由于疫情影响，餐馆都提早关门。看来，我只能自己回家做面吃了。

每当这时候，我都会想，要是父母在身边该多好。小时候，我放学回家，无论多晚，打开家门，总会有一股浓浓的香气扑鼻而来。“爸爸，妈妈！我回来了！好香啊！今天做了什么好吃的？”没等他们回应，我都会急忙往餐桌上凑。哇！是可口的土豆焖鸡和我最爱喝的排骨莲藕冬菇汤。我急忙去洗手，然后“飞”奔到餐桌前，用手捏起一块大大的鸡肉吃了起来。这时候，妈妈会脱下围裙，笑着说：“小馋猫，慢点吃。”爸爸则会不紧不慢地打开电视，调到新闻频道，开始他对我的家国情怀教育。爸爸有时候也会给我讲曾国藩，苏东坡等中国古代圣贤的故事。妈妈也会借机叮嘱我多练琴。有时候，我会给爸妈夹肉。可他们总会把肉放回我碗里，叮嘱我说：“你要多吃，你在长身体，爸妈要减肥。”

October 4, 2020October 7, 2020

La Cour se fonde sur la sentence arbitrale rendue après le procès pour déterminer la valeur en litige de la taxation d’un mémoire de frais – #34

Le jugement sur Langlois v. Langlois, 2020 QCCS 2959 nous enseigne que la « valeur en litige » au sens de l’ancien Tarif des honoraires judiciaires des avocats n’équivaut pas au « valeur du litige » . Il n’est pas nécessaire de trouver la valeur en litige dans les conclusions de la procédure. En effet, la greffière spéciale peut aller consulter « les procédures, les pièces, la sentence arbitrale après le procès etc. » pour déterminer cette valeur.

Les faits pertinents

Depuis 1987, trois générations de Langlois ont créé, établi, développé et investi dans l’entreprise familiale de transformation et de vente de crevettes, Crustacés des Monts inc. (ci-après « CDM »).

Depuis le début de l’année 2011, un conflit éclate entre les membres de la famille Langlois. Les demandeurs, Michel et Yvon, actionnaires minoritaires et administrateurs de CDM sont exclus et écartés de l’administration et de la gestion de CDM. Après avoir offert leurs actions à leurs coactionnaires pour un prix équivalent à leur juste valeur marchande, mais en vain, ils s’adressent à la Cour supérieure en vertu des articles 450 et suivants de la Loi sur les sociétés par actions (ci-après « LSA »), pour obtenir le rachat de leurs actions à leur valeur marchande. Les défendeurs demandent le rejet de toutes les conclusions recherchées dans la demande introductive d’instance.

September 20, 2020October 7, 2020

When his right to freely express himself hits her right to protect her reputation in the professional world – #33

“He filed a complaint against me at the professional association which is absolutely unfounded.” “He even solicited the help of third parties to obtain my Facebook account in my home country…””He left numerous negative comments about my business on social media, such as Google Reviews.” How can I protect myself effectively from those attacks? Am I entitled to compensatory, moral and punitive damages?

No freedom is absolute. While a person has right to freely express himself, a person also has right to the safeguard of his reputation and to respect for his private life. These fundamental rights are protected by the Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms (“Charter”) and, for the most part, recognized by the Civil Code of Quebec (“C.c.Q.”) as civil rights that every human being is entitled to their full enjoyment. An unlawful interference with a charter protected right entitles the victim to obtain compensation for the moral and material prejudice resulting therefrom. If intentional, punitive damages may also be awarded.

September 13, 2020October 7, 2020

Caron v. Attorney General of Canada: The Superior Court clarifies the proper interpretation of section 3(1)(b) of the Citizenship Act – #32

Benjamin was born in the Netherlands in a same-sex parented family. His Canadian citizenship application was refused by the government because there is no biological link between Benjamin and his Canadian parent, which was interpreted as an essential requirement for derivative citizenship according to section 3(1)(b) of the Citizenship Act (“Act”). Instead of applying for judicial review before the Federal Court of Canada, the plaintiffs seek an order declaring that the government’s interpretation of s. 3(1)(b) of the Act breached and continues to breach their Charter right to equality before the Superior Court of Quebec. Interestingly, the Attorney General of Canada also agrees with the plaintiffs that the government’s interpretation of s. 3(1)(b) brings it in conflict with s. 15(1) of Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (“Charter”). In July 2020, Mr. Justice Frédéric Bachand declared that in order to conform with Canadian human rights legislation as well as with the Charter, the interpretation requiring a biological link between Benjamin and his Canadian parent breaches his Charter right and that the terms “père et mère” in the French text should refer to both biological and legal parentage. This judgment protects same-sex couples’ rights to start and raise families of their own in Canada (Caron c. Attorney General of Canada, 2020 QCCS 2700).

September 6, 2020October 7, 2020

L’affaire Grand-Maison : L’accès au terrain du voisin et la réparation du préjudice – #31

Au Québec, le voisin peut avoir l’accès au votre terrain pour effectuer une construction sur son propre terrain lorsque les travaux ne peuvent pas être réalisés sans passer par votre terrain (Art. 987 C.c.Q.). Vous ne pouvez pas refuser l’accès à moins que vous ne puissiez démontrer que l’accès à votre terrain n’est pas nécessaire ou qu’il y a d’autres moyens d’effectuer les travaux (paragr. 23, Murphy c. Caldareri, 2008 QCCS 6721; page 395, LAFOND, Pierre-Claude, Précis de droit des biens, 2e édition). En outre, si l’accès au votre terrain vous cause des inconvénients anormaux, le voisin devient responsable de plein droit, sans qu’il y ait faute (Art. 976 C.c.Q.).